Hi Jeff !
I would ask where they first met, or first kissed. The last wedding I did they first kissed in an aircraft museum.....guess where I photographed them.....sometimes you try too hard to make an impression and the simplest answer is usually the best.
If your couple is from Salem, there is the House of the Seven Gables......or a waterfront shoot at sunset....something like that. I live near the beach here in Savannah and just mentioning the beach gets a positive response....
best I can think of, good luck !
Birk