Welcome to Mpix.com Community Sign in | Join | Help
Return to Mpix.com

in Search

New critique on my pics

Last post 08-17-2008 3:08 PM by general sloan. 14 replies.
Page 1 of 1 (15 items)
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  • 08-15-2008 10:04 PM

    New critique on my pics

    I was referred here by "the general".  I am a beginning photographer who would like to eventually persue a career as a photographer.  Please give me some feedback.


  • 08-15-2008 10:11 PM In reply to

    Re: New critique on my pics

    first off.. welcome! 

    The picture is too big and the entire thing can  not be seen.. please resize it to 660 on the long side.  I see lots of grain also, so please give your camera settings and we'll help

    :)

    Kelly
    My MPIX Friends--You Have My Permission To Play

    My motto: well said by several very smart MPIXERS...
    "Self-imposed limitations can be as crippling as debt. Photographers who have convinced themselves that clients won’t pay what is a reasonable price for their photography, often are merely projecting their own self-limiting values, but this can be a critical business mistake. A businessperson must be confident that he or she is providing value to clients, and that clients, in turn, will exchange that value for their hard-earned money. If this confidence is lacking, it is difficult to become successful in business......." because if you do EVERYTHING else right you are still DOA if you don't see the value of your work

    my myspace.. just ask me and I'll let you be my friend. http://www.myspace.com/kellyphotogia

    My Blog

  • 08-15-2008 10:13 PM In reply to

    Re: New critique on my pics

    In the future, please resize your images to 660pixels on the longer side. I think you did pretty good. Don't care too much for the vignette and the image looks a bit yellowish. Cute little one. BTW, welcome to the forum.

    Robert

    "You always have my permission to play with my images. CC are always welcome"

    Gear, Software, Hardware, Reading List & Websites
  • 08-15-2008 10:15 PM In reply to

    Re: New critique on my pics

    Hi, Carrie... Welcome to the forum...I am so glad you are here! I was wondering which image you would post first. Tell us about camera settings, boxes or strobes, etc. There are lots of people here that can provide good feedback. Is the vinette from the lens hood or did you do that in post? etc. CW
    It is typical for me to respond to initial posts before "reading" on...this way my initial thoughts aren't skewed by others'...but after that...rest assured, I have read them all!

  • 08-15-2008 10:28 PM In reply to

    Re: New critique on my pics

    You switched your imageConfused If you are trying to post more than one image, after posting your first image just click on reply and add the next one.

    Robert

    "You always have my permission to play with my images. CC are always welcome"

    Gear, Software, Hardware, Reading List & Websites
  • 08-15-2008 10:30 PM In reply to

    Re: New critique on my pics

    okay, I had a chance to look it over.. the shutter speed was 1/30, which is too slow for a toddler, I'd up it to at least 80, I'd go 125 if I could.  Looks like the flash hit across the T zone on the face (was this onboard flash?)  ISO was 400, I'd try to reduce that especially if you're using lights or flash. 

    I ran the image through noiseware, and cropped it differently, also made it b&w.


    Kelly
    My MPIX Friends--You Have My Permission To Play

    My motto: well said by several very smart MPIXERS...
    "Self-imposed limitations can be as crippling as debt. Photographers who have convinced themselves that clients won’t pay what is a reasonable price for their photography, often are merely projecting their own self-limiting values, but this can be a critical business mistake. A businessperson must be confident that he or she is providing value to clients, and that clients, in turn, will exchange that value for their hard-earned money. If this confidence is lacking, it is difficult to become successful in business......." because if you do EVERYTHING else right you are still DOA if you don't see the value of your work

    my myspace.. just ask me and I'll let you be my friend. http://www.myspace.com/kellyphotogia

    My Blog

  • 08-15-2008 10:31 PM In reply to

    Re: New critique on my pics

    Hey Carrie...I forget what editing software you use...let us know and we can help you resize it...CW
    It is typical for me to respond to initial posts before "reading" on...this way my initial thoughts aren't skewed by others'...but after that...rest assured, I have read them all!

  • 08-15-2008 10:31 PM In reply to

    Re: New critique on my pics

    okay.. you switched images now.... Please just reply and add another image instead of switching them out.. makes me look crazy!!  ha ha

    p.s. the new one is also too big

    Kelly
    My MPIX Friends--You Have My Permission To Play

    My motto: well said by several very smart MPIXERS...
    "Self-imposed limitations can be as crippling as debt. Photographers who have convinced themselves that clients won’t pay what is a reasonable price for their photography, often are merely projecting their own self-limiting values, but this can be a critical business mistake. A businessperson must be confident that he or she is providing value to clients, and that clients, in turn, will exchange that value for their hard-earned money. If this confidence is lacking, it is difficult to become successful in business......." because if you do EVERYTHING else right you are still DOA if you don't see the value of your work

    my myspace.. just ask me and I'll let you be my friend. http://www.myspace.com/kellyphotogia

    My Blog

  • 08-15-2008 10:36 PM In reply to

    Re: New critique on my pics

    photoguru:

    okay, I had a chance to look it over.. the shutter speed was 1/30, which is too slow for a toddler, I'd up it to at least 80, I'd go 125 if I could.  Looks like the flash hit across the T zone on the face (was this onboard flash?)  ISO was 400, I'd try to reduce that especially if you're using lights or flash. 

    I ran the image through noiseware, and cropped it differently, also made it b&w.

    I would agree...SS is HUGE when shooting toddlers. Carrie, If I remember right, you shoot with stobes, so the stobe people are going to help coach you with those.

    In studio, I am typically ISO = 400, F 2.8-5.6...and SS 125-300 depending on the drop and the subject. I never shoot less than ISO 400 on a baby or toddler because sometimes 125 doesn't even stop the action.

    Out of doors...that is different, and all this information will come in time.

    Take it one step at a time.

    It is typical for me to respond to initial posts before "reading" on...this way my initial thoughts aren't skewed by others'...but after that...rest assured, I have read them all!

  • 08-15-2008 10:37 PM In reply to

    Re: New critique on my pics

    On the image you have posted now, the eyes are too dark. Try a reflector or fill flash to get light in those eyes. One more thing it looks a little out of focus to me.

    Robert

    "You always have my permission to play with my images. CC are always welcome"

    Gear, Software, Hardware, Reading List & Websites
  • 08-15-2008 11:19 PM In reply to

    Re: New critique on my pics

    general sloan:
    photoguru:

    okay, I had a chance to look it over.. the shutter speed was 1/30, which is too slow for a toddler, I'd up it to at least 80, I'd go 125 if I could.  Looks like the flash hit across the T zone on the face (was this onboard flash?)  ISO was 400, I'd try to reduce that especially if you're using lights or flash. 

    I ran the image through noiseware, and cropped it differently, also made it b&w.

    I would agree...SS is HUGE when shooting toddlers. Carrie, If I remember right, you shoot with stobes, so the stobe people are going to help coach you with those.

    In studio, I am typically ISO = 400, F 2.8-5.6...and SS 125-300 depending on the drop and the subject. I never shoot less than ISO 400 on a baby or toddler because sometimes 125 doesn't even stop the action.

    Out of doors...that is different, and all this information will come in time.

    Take it one step at a time.

    I use outdoor light, so I'm learning from your indoor settings..  is the ss issue causing all the grain? 

    Kelly
    My MPIX Friends--You Have My Permission To Play

    My motto: well said by several very smart MPIXERS...
    "Self-imposed limitations can be as crippling as debt. Photographers who have convinced themselves that clients won’t pay what is a reasonable price for their photography, often are merely projecting their own self-limiting values, but this can be a critical business mistake. A businessperson must be confident that he or she is providing value to clients, and that clients, in turn, will exchange that value for their hard-earned money. If this confidence is lacking, it is difficult to become successful in business......." because if you do EVERYTHING else right you are still DOA if you don't see the value of your work

    my myspace.. just ask me and I'll let you be my friend. http://www.myspace.com/kellyphotogia

    My Blog

  • 08-16-2008 12:06 AM In reply to

    Re: New critique on my pics

    My guess is the camera she is using produces grain at 400 iso, or there was extra "light" i.e. a room light, window light, etc. and that all the different light sources caused the grain. I have seen that happen in many restaurant photos. Or, the original file was under exposed and the grain appeared when lightened in post. There are alot of things that could happen.

    I don't see grain in my photos until about 1000 ISO, but the 5D is that way.

    It is typical for me to respond to initial posts before "reading" on...this way my initial thoughts aren't skewed by others'...but after that...rest assured, I have read them all!

  • 08-17-2008 12:54 PM In reply to

    Re: New critique on my pics

    I had low lighting with this shot. It was when I first got my strobes a few months ago and was trying to figure out how to fire them using my son as my model.  This picture was actually taken with only the modeling light but I loved it so much.  I was hoping I could salvage it. I am trying to figure out photoshop but am not having a whole lot of luck.  I actually used picnik.com to edit this picture.   I think it is a good composition, but the grain and the lighting is all off.  I will post different ones as well that maybe show off my talent a little more.

  • 08-17-2008 12:56 PM In reply to

    Re: New critique on my pics

    I did the vinette in post editing.  Thanks for the welcome.  I will try to post info on my pics next time.

  • 08-17-2008 3:08 PM In reply to

    Re: New critique on my pics

    carrieclift:

    I did the vinette in post editing.  Thanks for the welcome.  I will try to post info on my pics next time.

    Carrie -- Post a couple more...in two threads, and we can all chime in and work with you on them.
    It is typical for me to respond to initial posts before "reading" on...this way my initial thoughts aren't skewed by others'...but after that...rest assured, I have read them all!

Page 1 of 1 (15 items)